Log In Login/Register | Help Help

Rio Grandes Third Division DVD

2 of 5 (1)
Rio Grandes Third Division DVD Greg Scholl Video Productions GSVP-081 604435008190
Click to enlarge
Note: Cover image may differ from actual product

The Gunnison line over Marshall Pass and the Monarch Branch were a part of the D&RGW(Rio Grande) Third Division, which started at Salida, Colorado. In this video we see films from 6 different sources with 95% of it color. We begin in Gunnison and watch engines at the servicing area and see the roundhouse. Later we ride the caboose right behind helper 492 and leaving the helper station at Sargeant, Colorado 492 is the rear pusher, with two more K-37 class engines on the front. After the three engine train we move to Salida and see action on the Monarch Branch as they haul limestone trains from the mine back to Salida. The first segment is single engine trains, then 2-engine trains.

In both instances the empties and loads must be split up at Maysville(ugrade), and Monarch(Downgrade return) because no more than 14 cars can fit in the stub of the Garfield switchback. We see this several times in the show, and great views shown including one half of the train moving with an engine on the middle section, and the other half moving at the lower segment after they were split.

There is also good coverage from several photographers of the run to Monarch, as well as switching and making up trains, plus turning the engines on the wye. In some cases we have two different angles of the same scenes which is interesting. We also enjoy the Rotary Barrel Dumper which transfers the narrow gauge loads into the standard gauge cars for the last segment of their journey to Pueblo, Colorado. This facility is well documented.

There are also cameo appearances of 2-8-0 #268 at the Chicago Worlds Fair in operation, plus a scene of the "Shavano" with engine 479 at Gunnison in the late 1930's. History and locations are either on the screen or narrated as we follow the action.

Near the end of the program we see engine 489 on work trains, including when the Monarch line was converted to Standard Gauge.

This is a good action show of rare footage from a by-gone era of steam railroading in Colorado.

54 Minutes

TVD Price:$ 26.95
List Price:$ 29.95
Live Stock Status: IN STOCK!
Ships Today! if ordered now. (PST)
When will I receive it?

Free Shipping on this item!

Award Value: 134 Points Earn points for free DVDsEarn points for free DVDs. Signup free.

DVD Item#:GSVP-081
Runtime:54 Mins ($0.50/min)
Producer:Greg Scholl Video Productions
Aspect Ratio:Full Screen
DVD UPC:604435008190
Shrink Wrapped?:Yes
Disc Type:DVD
Region Code:0 Worldwide NTSC

Rio Grandes Third Division DVD
DT (Colorado - Home of the Narrow Gauge) on 2016-01-17 18:49:28.

People who found this review helpful: 3

  •  2 of 5

Great scenery. Rare footage of Gunnison, Sargents, Marshall Pass, Mears Junction and Salida and its facilities.
The fantastic footage is totally ruined by an AWFUL AND INCESSANT MUSIC TRACK in place of dubbed train sounds (Somewhat amateurish narration also is a detraction)
In an era of digital sound and electronic editing it is almost criminal to produce a DVD without the appropriate "sounds of steam". (The classes of locomotive shown in this DVD still operate daily on the Durango and Silverton and Cumbres and Toltec railroads if new sound recordings were needed)
The noxious music make this potentially excellent video a complete disappointment

Additional remarks by DT:
Narration: Just enough.
Would kids enjoy this? I doubt it.
Image quality: Good.
DVD Value: Overpriced for the amount of enjoyment I got out of it.
Recommend to others? Definitely not!.

Respond to this review

Did you find this review useful?

Added 2016-01-18 21:07:50 by steamboy

listen to me. there is nothing wrong with the video itself. all of these scenes are 100% silent. there are other producers who dubbed fake sounds with silent footages. for example: the video rails classic collectors series. if you have those sets along with the sp overland route dvd, you'll know the differences.